The Middle Moffat by Eleanor Estes

The Middle Moffat, by Eleanor Estes, is the second book in her fictional series about the Moffat family.  This book won a Newberry Honor award in 1943.  Most of the stories in this book involve Jane.  Jane is a ten-year-old girl who lives with her mother, three siblings and cat during World War I.  Her father had died a few years earlier.  The Moffats have just moved in to a new house, and Jane feels somewhat forgotten within her family because she is a middle child.  She decides to call herself “the middle Moffat” so that she can feel like an important member of the family.

While introducing herself to the town’s oldest resident, Mr. Buckle, Jane accidently refers to herself as the “mysterious” middle Moffat.  Mr. Buckle is amused by the idea that Jane is mysterious in some way, so he decides to always call her the “mysterious middle Moffat.”  Jane just plays along with this new label because she wants to make a good first impression in her new neighborhood.  Mr. Buckle is 99 years old, and Jane makes it her personal goal to ensure that he survives to the age of 100.

Mr. Buckle is an important character in this book, but Jane is the main focus.  Each chapter is a different episode in her life.  I enjoyed reading about her adventures because it reminded me of what it feels like to be a child.  The stories are all memorable in their own way.  I especially enjoyed one chapter in which the Moffats were given a small parlor organ, only to realize later that it was full of moths.

I would have preferred for this book to focus more on Jane’s siblings, but I still enjoyed this book very much.  This is a great book about childhood and about learning to become independent.  The stories are very relatable and include many humorous situations.  This is a charming book that can be enjoyed by readers of all ages.

The Middle Moffat by Eleanor Estes is available to checkout from the Mission Viejo Library.

The Moffats by Eleanor Estes

The Moffats, by Eleanor Estes, is one of the author’s most well-known books, and the first in a series of four books. This book is about a family that consists of a mother, four children and a cat, living during World War I. The father had died a few years earlier. The children’s names are, from oldest to youngest, Sylvie, Joe, Jane and Rufus. One warm day in late summer, Jane is enjoying her day outside when a man named Mr. Baxter comes up to the Moffat’s house and nails on a sign that reads “for sale.” The Moffat children, and especially Jane, are very concerned by the sign. Their mother tells the children to try and forget about it, but it is difficult at first because they keep seeing the sign whenever they go in or out of the house. To make things worse, potential buyers stop by occasionally to inquire about the house.

The Moffats are able to forget about the sign for a while, but Jane gets increasingly annoyed by the sign. She cannot imagine living anywhere else, and she does not want to sell the house. Eventually, Jane gets so angry at the sign that she starts throwing mud balls at it. Afterward, while she is cleaning up the mess, a family named the Murdocks notices the sign and begins coming to the house every other day. The Moffat children resort to locking doors, closing windows and hiding whenever they sense the presence of one of the Murdocks. Jane wonders whether her family will ever get rid of the sign.

This book is really a collection of simple childhood adventures. The events seem quite ordinary, but the book is very well-written and engaging. The for-sale sign seems to be one of the main elements of the story, but this book is really about many small events from the perspective of a child. Jane seems to be the main character, and many of her observations are humorous even though she seems to overreact to things. This book is a good reminder of what it feels like to think as a child. The author does an excellent job of portraying life from a child’s perspective. I found it enjoyable to read about what happens to the children in the Moffat family, although I would have liked to learn more about the two older children. Sylvie is usually only mentioned, so I would have liked to read more about her. However, this is a very good children’s novel and I would recommend it to anyone in the mood for reading a simple and delightful book.

The Moffats by Eleanor Estes is available to check out from the Mission Viejo Library. It is also available to download for free from Libby.